I made this sauce when I was still swimming in gorgeous fresh tomatoes. Because the sauce is so simple, it really showcases them. That being said, the quality of the tomatoes used is very important.
There are many debates about this famous sauce online. Much of the discussion is about whether or not butter (and its richness) should be incorporated into a tomato sauce. My vote is “YES!” 🙂 After tasting it, I think most would agree with me. Other discussions revolve around dissatisfaction with the results compared to the “hype.” Comments about the sauce being soupy and underwhelming may stem from using lower quality tomatoes or an abbreviated cooking time. We loved it.
My intention was to freeze the sauce to enjoy it during the winter, but it was too delicious to wait. The debate about this sauce in my house was about what type of pasta to serve it with! 😉 My husband won with his choice of pappardelle. Great.
This recipe was adapted from Hazan Family Favorites: Beloved Italian Recipes by Guiliano Hazan, via Epicurious.com. I increased the cooking time and reserved the onions after removing them from the tomato mixture (I pureed and seasoned them to serve as a spread on toasted baguette slices). Using fresh instead of canned tomatoes may have altered the total cooking time. I more than doubled the cooking time in order to achieve my desired consistency. I also pureed the finished sauce. Addictive!
Yield: Makes enough sauce for 1 pound of pasta
- 2 pounds ripe tomatoes (or 3 cups canned whole peeled tomatoes with their juice, preferably San Marzano)
- 1 medium sweet yellow onion
- 5 tablespoons butter
- 1 1/4 teaspoons coarse salt
- 1/3 cup freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano, to finish
- If using fresh tomatoes, peel them: Score the base of each tomato and place it in a pot of boiling water for 30 seconds. Remove the tomato with a wire strainer and peel off the skin.
- Coarsely chop the fresh or canned tomatoes.
- Trim both ends of the onion; peel it and cut it in half lengthwise.
- Put the tomatoes, onion, butter, and salt in a 4- to 5-quart saucepan over medium heat. When the tomatoes begin to bubble, lower the heat to a slow but steady simmer. Cook, stirring every 10 to 15 minutes, until the tomatoes are no longer watery and the sauce has reduced, about 45 minutes to 2 hours, depending on the size and shape of the pot. (I used an enameled cast iron pot.) The sauce is done when the butter has separated from the tomatoes and there is no remaining liquid.
- Puree the finished sauce, if desired.
- Prepare one pound of pasta in boiling, salted water according to package directions.
- When you toss pasta with the sauce, add about 1/3 cup freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano.
Note: If the sauce is doubled, the cooking time will increase.
Two Years Ago:
Three Years Ago:
Four Years Ago:
Lovely sauce !
Worth every second of simmering! 😉
YES! Love this sauce, have made it before. And don’t you just love pappardelle noodles?
YES! SO happy to hear from you! ❤ This sauce was sooooo delicious. 🙂
Oh my totally satisfying dish 💯💞💞
I hope you get a chance to try it! 🙂
This looks so good. Simple but perfect with fresh pasta 🙂
It would be even more delicious with fresh pasta!
the answer to whether butter belongs in tomato sauce is ABSOLUTELY YES and i don’t trust anyone who says otherwise 😉 this sauce is my favorite!
True! Who are these people who don’t agree? 😉